On a radio interview and History and Hollywood

Tomorrow around 4 pm, the students in this course will be live on the air at the University of Alabama's radio station, discussing the upcoming "world premiere" of their music video featuring music by Bible Study at 5:30 pm December 3 at Jemison Mansion (UA Art History Emeritus Dr. Robert Mellown will be our guest speaker). Check them out tomorrow if you can by visiting 90.7.

On other fronts...as the semester draws to a close, I thought I’d take one last opportunity to share with you some of the thoughts of the students enrolled in this class. While we are still concerned with emerging urban life in America during the nineteenth century, I have challenged them to see how some of the issues we’ve addressed have across-time resonances.

During  two class meetings in the past two weeks, I did as much by asking them to look at two motion pictures. One is the 2013 documentary Muscle Shoals, which explores all of the great music that came out of one Alabama town as white and black bodies came together in a music studio, particularly during the late 1960s and early 1970s. I’d earlier invited them to see  the 1991 film The Commitments as a means of continuing to explore the cross-fertilization of music and cultures, but this time with working class white Dublin, Ireland front and center. But given that we had just ended Martha Sandweiss’ study on Clarence King, a nineteenth century geologist who is best known for having mapped the West for the U.S. government than for having passed as “black” in order to marry an African American woman after the Civil War, I figured it might be worthwhile (and risky) to pick another film, maybe one that pushed us to think about nationality, urban life, labor and race, but also secrets.

The students took took the bait and watched the 1996 motion picture Secrets & Lies, which concerns a black British professional woman’s  discovery that her birth mom, a factory worker, who had earlier given her up for adoption was white.  In this case, London was in the backdrop. Her half-sister, also white, is a street sweeper.

Regarding all three movies, I was quite concerned about how the “city” functions in terms of how certain bodies come together and part and how ideas about nationality and race and even gender can teach us something we hadn’t thought about it earlier when we were solely concentrated on urban life in America before the turn of the century.

 No matter the quality of their participation, or whether they participated at all, I want to thank the students for being open to this exercise, which is the sort that might be more fitting for a graduate class. I think they did pretty good. See excerpts from their short reflections on the “History and Hollywood” hand-out below (I want to thank my colleague Jimmy Mixson for sharing all of these prompts, which he uses in his course on medieval history).

While continuing to think deeply about the urban space in a maturing America, they were pushed to consider how a movie captures via story lines music, lighting, setting, costume, dialogues some of the things we’ve discussed including urbanization, women in public spaces in an urbanizing world, class and racial politics. Here are excerpts from the students’ replies to Secrets & Lies:

Caroline: In Secrets & Lies, the role and struggles of women can be seen through the different narratives. One woman struggles to enjoy her mundane housework; another woman experiences personal shame of coming face to face with her decision to give up her child for adoption; one woman is shocked at the realization that her birth mother is in fact white; and another young woman with “unladylike” manners [is a street sweeper] and doesn’t have much motivation to broader her horizons. 

This movie’s plot correlates well with Clarence King’s story. It shows that it is in fact not unusual to have a white or black relatives without physically looking like it...Class differences can be seen in this film [and Muscle Shoals].   In Muscle Shoals, it is seen with successful city people come to a simple rural part of Alabama. In Secrets & Lies, it is seen in the different professions of the newly discovered sisters. While one sister is an optometrist, another is a [street sweeper].
Similarities between the mother of the two sister and Clarence King can be made. The mother had a dark past that she probably tried to hide from her family and King deceived Ada Copeland every day …in order to keep them  both safe.

Wayne: The mother [who gave away her child years earlier] lives in a lower class area of London….Her brother doesn’t visit often because his wife doesn’t like [his sister]…The [entire family] has issues….The only one who was able to face the consequences of their decision was the adopted child. The racial and social separation within one family all draw them together towards the end.

Voni : Shelter is a common way in which we see city values emerge. [It] narrates who can afford certain luxuries.

Devon: The lighting [in Secrets & Lies] is kind of dark, but I think that is because of English weather.

Jasmine: When the [social worker] asked the mixed [race] woman about her childhood, I felt like she [revealed] the fact that she was [in fact] mixed and how she [herself] felt about it.

Here are the students’ replies to Muscle Shoals:

Rae: I grew up mere miles ...from Muscle Shoals. I think we always expect[ed] this deep cultural/musical development from this area. I would love to know what influenced the great musicians to produce this music. Was it because of rural influences that so greatly differed from the rural space?... The [music] studio [has resonances with] the drive that we see in people in the urban space. This drive to develop something, to succeed, to survive and to be something different. This movie truly gives us a look at what the “common humanity” that music has …for an entire generation of artists. Music that flowed from Muscle Shoals was able to transcend race and class in the 60s and 70s in Alabama and the world…The filmmaker juxtaposed a vivid rural panorama with short clips of industry, transportation, technology and natural resources. [These things] helped drive urbanization in the nineteenth century and was influencing an area [that was] not so urban.

Caroline: In Muscle Shoals, many aspects of urbanization were depicted. We get to see how women in public, especially strong women like Etta James and Aretha Franklin, was more widely accepted and even admired [unlike in the nineteenth century]. These women had a major impact on the music industry…The relationships between the black and white musicians [was an] incredible improvement [from the past]. The artists didn’t let the struggle between their races get in the way of what they were trying to make…The filmmakers were very deliberate with their portrayals of Muscle Shoals. After a big name artist or producer would talk about their incredible soul and magic in the town, the filmmaker [chose] to depict the stillness and natural beauty of Muscle Shoals. I think this was done to display how ironic it must have been to those performers that a place like this could create such a phenomenon.

Jeff: The music that came from...Muscle Shoals [was] some of the greatest hits [and] should forever be considered some of the greatest music because it came from the heart....It was music that moved...millions around the world.

Wayne: The movie notes how soulful rivers seem to develop near rivers and "seems to come out of the mud." Musically, the film uses long, sorrowful guitar chords and also folk style music during interviews. Yet, the music highlighted in the film is funk, rock 'n roll and soul music. The rock 'n roll and soul music played an important role in urban areas because it allowed people from different ethnic and cultural backgrounds to develop a sense of unity [as they] became interested in new music. However, the music that helped urban [people] was produced in an area with high racial tension and by men who considered themselves to be "country folk."

Devon: The people who wanted to record  or play with the band from Muscle Shoals all expected them to be black. Everyone seemed to think that only certain types of people could play that type of music. However, everyone who worked there did so because of their passion for music.

Ben: I wished the film discussed what happened to Muscle Shoals as a music hub as not many hits come from it anymore. Was there an event or simply the change [in] popular culture away from funk and soul [that contributed to the decline]?

Jasmine: The scene showing the large bridges and dams as well as the big power plant and train shows urbanization in Muscle Shoals.

Finally, the students were also asked to share the unanswered questions that a particular film left them with and tell me whether they think film is an appropriate medium for teaching history (This issue is extremely important to me. I noticed when I used 1940s and 1950s films about America and even Europe's urban and frontier past in last year's class, the students with few exceptions - such as the time I showed  Bend of the River  starring James Stewart and Rock Hudson or Little Old New York starring Alice Daye - seemed bored. This time, more of them paid more attention as I cautiously used more recent films as teaching tools).

On the issue of whether film is an appropriate medium for teaching history, here's what some of them had to say:

Ben: I’d say [film] is a very good tool for anything from American history, music history or cultural history.

Emily: Films are never perfect. They don’t always apply perfectly to a lesson. They sometimes strive from accuracy for a good story.

Voni:  Film allows for a more interactive way of learning especially for visual learners. The disadvantages of film, like any media, that the creator has an objective they are trying to portray so we must extract the history from that.  

Undre: Film produces a teaching experience that can be interactive. This interactive lesson could come from pausing the video and discussing how it relates to the topic of the class. Disadvantages of using film could be that lesson valuable to the curriculum are over-kill [for]  students paying attention to the wrong elements of the movie. Another disadvantage can come from using non-biased films to teach a biased lesson.

Jasmine: The film [Muscle Shoals] is great for showing the emerging urban life in Alabama. It is a virtual time line not only covering music, but it also covers what is going on in the world outside of music (for example, the clip about Martin Luther King Jr. and clips of the segregation at the University of Alabama).

Wayne: I am a visual learner. I enjoy seeing images of urban areas and visually seeing personal expressions of racial and cultural situations....Muscle Shoals [in particular] is very useful as a medium for teaching history. Its advantages are that it is able to [present] American life outside the studio while also providing entertaining songs that most can sing along to...[The music] studio presented was a great example of the great [things] that can happen when open-mindness is allowed.

Rae: Film does a great job of illustrating history in a way textbooks can't. However, film can skew history or present it very one-sided. 

Jeff: [Film] is [an] appropriate medium because it is...entertaining. [But] sometimes it doesn't portray the entire history; just what [the filmmakers] want to show us.